Discovery · Decision memo

Decision memo

Musterwerk Antriebstechnik GmbH

Situation
An audit finding and an end-of-life deadline
Access
Tier B
Prepared by
Aleph Engineering GmbH
Version
1.0, reviewed by a second engineer

Scope and limits

Systems examined
ERP, Customer portal, Nightly sync, EDI link
Context only
AuftragsPlaner, Shop-floor data, File server, Document archive, Quality system, HR and payroll, Drive and Sheets, Excel workbooks, Shared mailboxes
Period
10 business days
Access
Tier B, read-only technical inspection: Approved read-only access to named repositories, configuration, build and deployment setup, or infrastructure views.
Exclusions
No production data, no changes to any system, no security testing beyond configuration review.
Confidence
High for the configuration, code, and integration design. The sync's actual failure rate is inferred from complaints.

Recommendation

Modernization

Modernize in three stages: close the urgent exposure, replace the nightly file exchange, and move the portal to a supported platform. No rewrite.

Reasons and evidence

  1. 01The audit findings are about configuration, platform, and password storage, all fixable without rebuilding the portal (F1-F3).
  2. 02The fragile sync is the cause of the wrong delivery dates customers see (F4).
  3. 03Moving the integration to the ERP's standard interface also removes the main obstacle to the ERP upgrade (F5).
  4. 04Each stage can be shipped and reversed on its own, and the first one fits within days.

Alternatives considered

Upgrading the server in place
Fixes the end-of-support date but leaves the manual deployment and silent sync failures.
A new portal
Costs more and takes longer, without solving the integration problem.
Application Managed Services first
Operating the portal as it is would not close the audit.

Next step

If Musterwerk decides to proceed, the attached project definition is the basis for a proposal. If not, all outputs remain Musterwerk's to use.

Decision

Decided by
Thomas Keller, Managing Director
Presented in
Closing session, day 10
Corrections
Within five business days of the closing session

← Back to the guided tour